As my client shared his question, I smiled because it took me back almost twenty years. I told him about a leadership programme I attended back then where we were discussing different leadership styles. I confidently announced to the group that I was mostly democratic, because I always asked my team for their opinion before making important decisions. One of my colleagues, who had worked with me on several projects, looked at me and said. "Yes, that's what you think! You always ask us for our opinion, but then you make the decision yourself."
I had confused consultation with democratic leadership
It was one of those moments where someone holds up a mirror and exposes a blind spot. At the time, I genuinely believed I was leading in a democratic way. What I hadn't appreciated was that asking for input and sharing decision-making aren't the same thing.
The lesson that my colleague gave me is one that I now find myself sharing with many of my coaching clients. As they begin to ask more open questions, listen more carefully and involve their teams more than before they wonder if making the final decision somehow means they're slipped back into old command-and-control habits. It doesn't. Collaborative leadership isn't about giving up decision-making. It's about knowing when to involve others and when to provide direction.
As leaders, it's easy to become attached to a particular style. But the most effective leaders adapt their approach to what the situation requires. Sometimes they bring the team together because different perspectives will lead to a better outcome. Sometimes they step aside because someone else has the expertise to decide. And sometimes they make the decision themselves because the team needs clarity and direction.
Beware of false consultation
There's another trap that many collaborative leaders fall into. They ask for everyone's opinion but have already made up their mind. Most teams recognise this immediately and end up with a bitter taste in their mouth.
Of course, there will be situations when you hear everyone's views and still reach a different conclusion. (Perhaps you've considered risks the team isn't aware of, or your wider accountability means you have information they don't.) But if you have already made the decision, don't pretend you're consulting the team. Explain your reasoning instead. If you ask for people's input, be genuinely open to being influenced by what they say. Otherwise, they’ll feel deceived. People don't expect to be consulted on every decision, but they do expect honesty.
Four questions to guide your leadership approach
The next time you're faced with an important decision, ask yourself these four questions.
1. Whose decision should this be?
Not every decision belongs to the project manager. Some are best made by the team because shared ownership is essential. Others belong to a technical specialist because they have the expertise. And some decisions genuinely sit with you. Being clear about decision ownership is the first step.
2. What input do I need before making the decision?
Even when the final decision is yours, you don't have to make it in isolation. Ask yourself:
- Who has expertise I don't?
- Who sees risks I may have missed?
- Who has a different perspective that could improve the outcome?
The quality of a decision often depends on the quality of the conversa-tion that comes before it.
3. How important is commitment?
Not every decision requires consensus. But some decisions only succeed if people genuinely support them. If successful implementation depends on commitment, involving the team in the discussion—or even in making the decision—can dramatically increase buy-in. The aim isn't to involve people for the sake of it. It's to create the level of ownership the situation requires.
4. What does this situation need from me?
This is the question that brings everything together. Does the situation call for coaching, a team discussion, a clear decision, or should someone else take the lead? Don't become attached to one style. Adapt.
The Real Shift
Moving away from command-and-control leadership doesn't mean becoming hesitant or indecisive. It means becoming more intentional about how you lead. The next time you're faced with an important decision, resist the temptation to ask: Should I make the decision? Instead ask yourself: What does this situation need from me?
The answer won't always be the same, and that's exactly the point
For more resources, check out:
Books:
How to Do the Inner Work
The Power of Project Leadership
Blog Posts:
What Makes a High Performing Team
How to Become a Better Coach
How to Deepen Your Communication
Innovative Leaders Ask Powerful What-If Questions
The Yin & Yang of Project Leadership

RSS Feed